Local Government Accountability

Survey Complete

Thank You

Your answers have been recorded.

The Verdict

It's time for new leadership that will actually scrutinize spending100%
Give the incumbents another chance to course-correct0%
I'm satisfied with the current direction0%
Unsure0%

Awareness Gaps

Percentage of voters who had no prior knowledge of each fact

Right now, before any facts — how likely are you to re-elect Commissioner Joe Neunder (District 4) on August 18?0%

Right now, before any facts — how likely are you to re-elect Commissioner Mark Smith (District 2) on August 18?0%

Is Sarasota County government headed in the right direction or the wrong direction?0%

FACT: County spending grew from $823M to $1.22 BILLION (+48%) in three years — 6x faster than the population. Both voted YES on every budget. ZERO no votes. Did you know?0%

FACT: Bonded debt more than DOUBLED — $484M to $1.11B — 30-year debt your grandchildren inherit. Both voted YES on every bond. Did you know?0%

FACT: Smith warned "We're spending money we won't have" — then voted YES on the record $2.524 BILLION budget. Did you know?0%

FACT: They approved a nearly $100M administration building by the Celery Fields — bond-financed, no public discussion — while the average worker earns $45,229. Did you know?0%

FACT: "Small government" Sarasota ranks #6 of 67 Florida counties for administrative bureaucracy — $4,688 per resident, more than Palm Beach, Hillsborough, and Pinellas. Did you know?0%

FACT: $18.1 MILLION for a 2-acre boatyard — the seller had paid $8.9M two years earlier, a 103% profit on your dime. Did you know?0%

FACT: Population grew about 8%. Inflation accounts for roughly another 12–15%. Together that justifies a spending increase of about 20%. Instead spending rose 48% and debt rose 76% — leaving roughly $200 MILLION in spending that growth and inflation cannot explain. Were you aware?0%

NOW KNOWING THE FACTS: How likely are you to re-elect Joe Neunder (District 4)?0%

NOW KNOWING THE FACTS: How likely are you to re-elect Mark Smith (District 2)?0%

Two challengers — Jim DeNiro, a 30-year Sarasota PD sergeant endorsed by the Florida PBA, and Kristina Sargent, a U.S. Army and Army National Guard veteran and former prosecutor — are running on written commitments to audit the spending, restore reserves, and stop the debt. Would you consider a reform challenger?0%

Next Survey

What happens next for Sarasota?

Where the Challengers Stand

Take the Next Survey →

LGAI Analysis

What the Record Shows

LGAI’s live analytical findings on the Sarasota County fiscal record and the August 18 primary.

See the Live Analysis →

Methodology

  • AI-driven fiscal audit of all Sarasota County Comprehensive Annual Financial Reports, FY 2021–2025
  • Sarasota County CAFR, FY 2021–2025, audited by CliftonLarsonAllen LLP
  • Sarasota County Board of County Commissioners meeting minutes
  • Florida Office of Economic and Demographic Research, FY 2024
  • U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2023

About LGAI

LGAI is an independent research organization that conducts forensic analysis of local government finances. We turn complex public records into clear, verifiable findings so citizens can hold their government accountable.

Learn more about LGAI

About SarasotaCountyFacts.org

SarasotaCountyFacts.org is LGAI’s Sarasota County investigative project. Our reporting tracks county fiscal decisions, bond authorizations, and commissioner voting records—sourced exclusively to audited financial records and public meeting transcripts.

Read the 21 findings →

© 2026 Local Government Accountability™. All facts cited in this survey are sourced to official audited government records. This survey is for research and public-interest purposes. Unbiased going in; accountable coming out.